How the comparison works
Buying: you pay a down payment plus about 7% in stamp duty, registration and brokerage, then an EMI, plus yearly upkeep and property tax. Your wealth is the home's value minus the loan left.
Renting: you pay rent, and invest the down payment and the 7% buying costs on day one. Every month you also invest the gap between what the buyer pays (EMI and upkeep) and your rent. Your wealth is the investments.
The home's price growth and your investment return are the two numbers that decide the result.
Worked example
An ₹80 lakh home, 20% down, a 20-year loan at 8.5% (EMI about ₹55,541), against renting at ₹25,000 a month. Home price rises 6% a year, rent rises 6%, upkeep is 0.5% of the price, and investments earn 8%:
| After | Buy: home value − loan left | Rent: investments |
|---|---|---|
| 5 years | ₹50.7 lakh | ₹54.6 lakh |
| 10 years | ₹98.5 lakh | ₹97.1 lakh |
| 15 years | ₹1.65 crore | ₹1.52 crore |
Renting is ahead for the first 5 years, the two are level around year 10, and buying is about ₹13 lakh ahead after 15 years. Change the numbers and the answer flips:
- If the home rises 4% a year instead of 6%, renting wins.
- If investments earn 9% instead of 8%, renting wins even after 15 years.
- If rent rises 8% a year instead of 6%, buying wins by much more.
What to look at before deciding
- The rent-to-price ratio. If yearly rent is under 3% to 3.5% of the price, buying is expensive relative to renting. See the rental yield calculator.
- The EMI against rent. An EMI of ₹55,541 against rent of ₹25,000 means you pay more than twice as much each month to own. Check yours with the SBI home loan calculator.
- Up-front costs. Stamp duty and registration are 5% to 7% of the price. See the stamp duty calculator.
- How long you will stay. Buying costs are heavy in the first years. Staying under about 7 years usually favours renting.
- Tax benefits. Under the old regime, interest up to ₹2 lakh and principal within Section 80C reduce tax. See the income tax calculator.
- Non-money factors. Security, freedom to modify and stability are real, but so are the ability to move for a job and keep savings liquid.