Rent vs Buy Calculator

By Vishal Jethwani · Last reviewed · How we check our numbers

Buying a home and renting one both cost money, but they build wealth in different ways. This calculator compares the net worth you end up with under each choice after the years you pick. The worked example is an ₹80 lakh home with a 20% down payment against renting at ₹25,000 a month.

Interactive Sandbox

Buying leaves you

₹0

Renting and investing leaves you

₹0

Better option

-

AfterBuy: home value − loan leftRent: investmentsAhead

Buying includes 7% for stamp duty, registration and brokerage. The renter invests the down payment and those costs, then invests (or draws down) the monthly gap between the buyer's outgo and the rent. Results are estimates and change a lot with the growth rates you assume.

Advertisement

Worked example

A ₹80,00,000 home with 20% down and a 20-year loan at 8.5%, against renting a similar home at ₹25,000 a month, compared after 15 years:

Monthly EMI
₹55,541
Buying leaves you
₹1,64,65,347
Renting and investing leaves you
₹1,51,55,258
Net worth by year
AfterBuy: home value − loan leftRent: investments
1 years₹22,07,375₹27,53,986
5 years₹50,65,665₹54,59,188
10 years₹98,47,177₹97,09,487
15 years₹1,64,65,347₹1,51,55,258

Change any input in the calculator above to run your own numbers.

Advertisement

How the comparison works

Buying: you pay a down payment plus about 7% in stamp duty, registration and brokerage, then an EMI, plus yearly upkeep and property tax. Your wealth is the home's value minus the loan left.

Renting: you pay rent, and invest the down payment and the 7% buying costs on day one. Every month you also invest the gap between what the buyer pays (EMI and upkeep) and your rent. Your wealth is the investments.

The home's price growth and your investment return are the two numbers that decide the result.

Worked example

An ₹80 lakh home, 20% down, a 20-year loan at 8.5% (EMI about ₹55,541), against renting at ₹25,000 a month. Home price rises 6% a year, rent rises 6%, upkeep is 0.5% of the price, and investments earn 8%:

AfterBuy: home value − loan leftRent: investments
5 years₹50.7 lakh₹54.6 lakh
10 years₹98.5 lakh₹97.1 lakh
15 years₹1.65 crore₹1.52 crore

Renting is ahead for the first 5 years, the two are level around year 10, and buying is about ₹13 lakh ahead after 15 years. Change the numbers and the answer flips:

  • If the home rises 4% a year instead of 6%, renting wins.
  • If investments earn 9% instead of 8%, renting wins even after 15 years.
  • If rent rises 8% a year instead of 6%, buying wins by much more.

What to look at before deciding

  1. The rent-to-price ratio. If yearly rent is under 3% to 3.5% of the price, buying is expensive relative to renting. See the rental yield calculator.
  2. The EMI against rent. An EMI of ₹55,541 against rent of ₹25,000 means you pay more than twice as much each month to own. Check yours with the SBI home loan calculator.
  3. Up-front costs. Stamp duty and registration are 5% to 7% of the price. See the stamp duty calculator.
  4. How long you will stay. Buying costs are heavy in the first years. Staying under about 7 years usually favours renting.
  5. Tax benefits. Under the old regime, interest up to ₹2 lakh and principal within Section 80C reduce tax. See the income tax calculator.
  6. Non-money factors. Security, freedom to modify and stability are real, but so are the ability to move for a job and keep savings liquid.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy a house in India?

It depends on price growth, rent, your loan rate and how long you stay. In many metros the rent is only 2% to 3% of the price a year, which makes renting cheaper month to month.

How much does buying a house cost over renting?

Add the EMI, upkeep, property tax and the lost return on your down payment, and compare with rent plus the investment growth you would get instead.

What return do I need on investments for renting to win?

With the example numbers, a little over 8.5% a year. The higher your investment return and the lower the home's price growth, the better renting looks.

Does a home loan make buying cheaper?

A loan lets you buy with less money up front, but at 8.5% the interest is a real cost. Total interest on a 20-year loan can be close to the price itself.

When does buying clearly win?

When you plan to stay 10 years or more, prices in your area keep rising, and you actually save the difference rather than spending it. ## Disclaimer This is an estimate that depends on the assumptions you enter. Future prices and returns are uncertain. It is not financial advice.

Share:
Disclaimer: This calculator gives estimates from the inputs you enter. Your actual result depends on the rules applied by your bank, employer or the government on the day. sbicalculator.com is an independent site and is not affiliated with State Bank of India. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.

Advertisement

Advertisement